Genetika-guppy.my1.ru

Japan Blue is Independent gene - not Base body color.
It is Vladimir's photo also.

Yes. Base body color for Japanise Blue must have 3-4 dominant genes for good colors.

But Japanise Blue is independent gene - for example, strain of Japanise Blue with mgex genotype (full recessive).

Respect must be given to practical results.

Добавлено (16.05.2010, 09:37)
---------------------------------------------
Here is my defense of Vladimir Storozhev and Dr. Sergey Apryatin: http://guppylacelovers.com/forums/index.php?topic=136.0

Here is BODY:

In defense of Dr. Sergey Apryatin, I have to say this:

Seeing is believing; and, "the proof is in the pudding."

Dr. Sergey Apryatin can, at the very least, produce physical PROOF of his position. Vladimir Storozhev can produce - for just an example - myriad Blue Lace Snakeskins using various formulas, when Mr. Shaddock cannot even define a Lace Snakeskin, let alone produce a Blue one !!!!!!!!!!!!!! This is self-evident to even the Blind Man! As Dr. Sergey Apryatin claims, "He has the proof!"

Mr. Shaddock admits in his own words that he is not conducting "scientific research" and that his work is full of errors - very admirable and honest. So, why does he accuse Dr Sergey Apryatin's Russian Table of lacking scientific footing and being "full of holes"?

In the final analysis, disproving one DOES NOT prove the other. In 2010, when it comes to guppy genetics, it is speculative! 99% of all scientific research done is performed on labratory strains. You do not believe? Ask the premier Fancy Show Guppy Breeder in your country when the last time a University or Scientific Establishment asked them for stock for research.

Here in America, Steve Rybicki, of AngelsPlus, was asked for Fancy Show Strains for a study regarding inbreeding. Does this help you with your question of how a Wide Caudal is inherited? I think not.

Gentle reader, you must realize that in Canines (dogs), for example, the inheritence (genetics) for every known trait or phenotype is KNOWN 100%! Only various diseases like hypothyroidism or hip dysplasia remain somewhat obscure.

Mr. Shaddock wants to bring forth "practicing geneticists" for witnesses. This is comical. As Dr. Sergey Apryatin would say, "100% correct theory; no practical resume." If you were to invite the PREMIER Professor of Genetics into your home tomorrow, they would not be able to tell you the genetics of a Half Black Pastel Guppy (German Yellow).

They can only speak upon the genetic theory of their species of expertise.
Fellow entusiasts, PLEASE wake up! I emplore you for the good of the hobby. Save your money. Do not buy these ridiculous speculative books!

"Пишут не пером, а умом"! Русская народная пословица.

Mr.Shaddock should have postponed writing book until all evidence examined.

Добавлено (18.05.2010, 00:57)
---------------------------------------------
Anthony Fischinger proposed a similar table to Mr. Shaddock years ago, and was not listened to, either. Mr. Shaddock close ears if theory different from his own. Always.

I tried to dicuss things with Mr.Shaddock and he would grow bored if he did not understand. My only hope is that guppy community look at ALL the evidence.

Добавлено (23.05.2010, 10:34)
---------------------------------------------
Mr. Shaddock has now been "called-out" for the World to see. He will continue to sell books to those who want to see "pretty pictures"; but, in time, his words will see no proof in results!

Genetics of guppy is complicated. One cannot make 5 or 6 crosses and publish results as science! Guppy hobbyists use many different strains - few HOMOZYGOUS! Results will vary!

I say, let Vladimir Storozhev, Gernot Kaden, Noroburu Iwasaki, and Stan Shubel SPEAK! : D

по просьбе Philip Shaddock был выложен перевод его статьи и некоторые отрывки дисскуссий на Guppy Designer Facebook.
http://www.dgv-forum.de/t1805f7....ms.html

В предисловии говорится, что Philip Shaddock долго размышлял о необходимости "немецкого" перевода, т.к., по его словам, не хотел ссор/распрей в европейской Guppy-сцене.

Jakob